Look, I’m not saying I cried into my coffee during a readathon because a fictional Olympic swimmer couldn’t remember his estranged father’s seaweed rice. I’m just saying it happened. At 6 AM. Before I was fully conscious.
This is what Hisashi Kashiwai does to you.
The Restaurant of Lost Recipes is the second book in the Kamogawa Food Detectives series, and if you’re expecting Miss Marple with miso, you’re going to be disappointed. There are no murders here. No theft. No scandal. Just six people who walk into a nondescript Kyoto diner asking an impossible question: Can you recreate a dish I ate twenty years ago that I can barely remember but desperately need to taste again?
The answer, impossibly, is yes.
Nagare Kamogawa, a retired detective turned chef, and his daughter Koishi run what appears to be a regular restaurant. But word has gotten around (how, we’re never told, which adds to the magic) that they offer a very specific service. Tell them everything you remember about a lost dish, wait two weeks, and Nagare will serve you that exact meal. Not similar. Not close. Exact.
And here’s where it gets interesting: these aren’t people chasing nostalgia for fun. They’re stuck. The Olympic swimmer can’t reach out to his dying father. The model can’t tell her wealthy fiancé about her humble origins. The couple who lost their son can’t move forward. Each person needs that specific taste to unlock something they’ve been unable to face.
I picked this up because the first book, The Kamogawa Food Detectives, reminded me of the Japanese show Midnight Diner, except with actual resolution instead of that melancholy “life goes on” vibe. I love food stories. I love the Korean concept of 어머니의 손맛 (eomeonui sonmat), that untranslatable phrase meaning the unique, irreplaceable flavor of a mother’s cooking, imbued with love and attention you can taste but never quite replicate.
Kashiwai gets this. Every single story understands that food is never just food.
What Makes This Book Work (And Why I’m Still Thinking About It)
The structure is deceptively simple. Six stories, same pattern: client arrives, gets interviewed by Koishi (who has zero patience for vagueness), waits two weeks, returns for the reveal. It should feel repetitive. It doesn’t. Because the ritual itself becomes comforting. You know what’s coming, and that predictability creates space for emotional depth.
The food descriptions are obscene. I mean this as the highest compliment. Kashiwai apparently cooks every dish himself before writing about it, and you can tell. When he describes tempura, you can hear the crackle. When he writes about fried rice, you can smell the sesame oil. I’ve never wanted to eat a book before, but here we are.
It’s low stakes in the best way. Nothing explodes. Nobody dies (well, except in backstory). The tension comes from whether a retired chef can successfully bake his first-ever Christmas cake to honor a dead child. And somehow, that’s more gripping than most thrillers I’ve read.
They acknowledge the dead mother. Kikuko, Nagare’s late wife, appears in every chapter via a photograph and shrine in the back interview room. She’s present without being maudlin, honored without being sainted. It’s the kind of grief representation that feels true: she’s gone, they miss her, life continues.
Drowsy the cat is perfect. This cat spends the entire book trying to sneak into the dining room and getting redirected. That’s it. That’s the subplot. It works.
7 Things This Book Taught Me About Memory, Food, and Moving Forward
1. Taste is the most powerful time machine we have
Ratatouille knew it. Kashiwai knows it. Your grandmother’s chicken soup isn’t just chicken soup. It’s every Sunday afternoon of your childhood compressed into one bowl. The novel explores how recreating these tastes isn’t about living in the past but about integrating those memories into who you are now.
2. Sometimes memories need correction, not accuracy
Here’s where it gets brilliant: Nagare occasionally tweaks recipes because he understands his clients are trapped in false memories that are keeping them stuck. The goal isn’t historical accuracy. It’s emotional truth. He’s not recreating the past. He’s creating the meal they need now.
3. Ritual creates safety for emotional processing
The two-week waiting period isn’t arbitrary. It gives clients time to sit with what they’ve asked for. The predictable structure of each visit (preliminary meal, interview, return visit) creates a container where healing can happen. In our chaos-addicted culture, this feels radical.
4. Authenticity requires vulnerability
The fried rice story kills me. A successful model can’t tell her wealthy fiancé that her mother made “pink” fried rice with cheap ingredients because she’s ashamed of her origins. Nagare recreates it perfectly, and suddenly she has the courage to be honest. Food becomes the language for “this is who I really am.”
5. Small acts of service change lives
Nagare and Koishi don’t cure cancer. They make lunch. Yet every client leaves transformed. The novel argues that meaningful work doesn’t require grand gestures, just genuine attention to what someone actually needs.
6. Grief needs acknowledgment, not erasure
The Christmas cake story (bring tissues) centers on parents who haven’t processed their son’s death. Instead of encouraging them to “move on,” Nagare honors their loss by baking a cake he’s never attempted before. The act of making it becomes its own kind of mourning ritual.
7. Connection happens through shared experience, not just words
While Koishi conducts verbal interviews, the actual healing occurs when clients taste the dish. Some truths are better communicated through flavor than language. This book trusts sensory experience in ways most contemporary fiction doesn’t.
Who Should Read This (And Who Should Skip It)
Read it if you:
- Consider “low stakes” high praise
- Believe food is a legitimate form of emotional communication
- Enjoyed the first installment, Before the Coffee Gets Cold or Sweet Bean Paste
- Are currently navigating grief and need something gentle
- Think detailed food descriptions are as good as plot
- Want to cry in a good way
Skip it if you:
- Need plot twists and dramatic reveals
- Find episodic structures boring
- Don’t care about food beyond fuel
- Want complex character psychology
- Prefer experimental narrative structures
- Can’t handle themes of loss right now
Final Thoughts: The Magic of Ordinary Things
Here’s what I keep thinking about: we live in a culture obsessed with the extraordinary. Grand gestures. Big moments. Dramatic transformations. Kashiwai proposes something different: maybe what we need most is someone paying close attention to the ordinary things we’ve lost.
A seaweed bento. A pink fried rice. A Christmas cake. These aren’t fancy dishes. They’re the food of everyday life, made with attention and love. And somehow, that’s everything.
I finished this book wanting two things: to call my mother and ask her to teach me her recipes before I forget them, and to eat every single dish Nagare prepared. Since I can’t do the latter (no Kamogawa Diner in Singapore, sadly), I’m settling for the former.
The restaurant of lost recipes exists in all of us. It’s every meal our mothers made that we took for granted. Every dish we ate with people no longer here. Every flavor we can remember but can’t quite recreate. Kashiwai reminds us that these losses matter, that food connects us across time, and that sometimes the most profound magic is just someone caring enough to get the recipe exactly right.
Have you read The Restaurant of Lost Recipes? What’s your 어머니의 손맛 (eomeonui sonmat), that irreplaceable dish from your childhood? Drop your thoughts in the comments. And if you’ve cried over fictional food, you’re my people.
jujucation.com 